26 Jan BLOOD SPOTS IN EGGS
While preparing a dish for cooking, one is often unsure if he has to check the eggs for blood spots. In addition, companies receive eggs in various forms and the question arises if these eggs need to be checked? Does the halacha of checking for blood spots apply today? If it does, who is required to check to see if there are blood spots in the eggs?
These issues and others will be discussed at length below.
Background
In past years, most eggs came from fertile hens, whose hormone levels stimulated more egg production. Today, this is not the case. The hormones are stimulated artificially, the chickens themselves are not fertile and the eggs will not develop into chickens. About a hundred years ago, chicken farms became very common. On a chicken farm only chickens are raised. The chickens only produce eggs and they are not killed for consumption. Chickens which are used for the production of eggs can produce eggs every day of the year.
The Issur
It is forbidden for one to eat any blood found in an egg. The reason is not related to the issur of eating blood, but is because the blood in the egg is an indication that a new embryo is forming, and it is forbidden to eat an embryo.
Blood Spots
In the times of the Gemorah, blood appeared in eggs because of two reasons: 1. The egg had been fertilized and a chicken embryo was being produced. 2. An irregularity in the hen causes a small amount of blood to be deposited in the egg.
In the United States, the government requires that Grade A and Grade AA eggs be checked for blood spots, through a procedure called candling. During the candling, the eggs are held before a light in a dark room allowing any blood spots to be easily detected. Accordingly, the chance of finding a blood spot is rare.
The Halacha
The Gemorah in Chulin quotes the halacha of blood spots in eggs. There is a discussion in the poskim as to the exact parameters of this issur. Most say that any blood found in the egg because of fertilization is ossur and the egg must be discarded. Some say it depends on where the blood is found: only in the yolk (yellow part of the egg), in the albumin (egg white) or in both the yolk and the albumin.
The Rama says because of the difficulty with this halacha, the custom is that there is no difference where the blood is found and the entire egg is forbidden.
Checking Eggs Today
The above discussion was referring to blood spots which might be from a fertilized egg, and where there is a possibility to transgress an issur by eating the developing embryo. However, the Shulchan Aruch says eggs which are from a coop where there are no roosters may be eaten, even if the hen sat on the eggs for many days. Nonetheless, one has to remove any blood spot which is found. The Shach says that even the blood spot is permitted to be eaten since this egg was not fertilized. The Gr’a says failing to remove the blood is an issur d’rabanan.
The Rama says one who is making a dish with eggs should check the eggs to make sure there is no blood present in the egg. The Aruch Ha’shulchan says this is the custom in all of klal yisroel. The idea of checking is not according to the letter of the law but is a custom. If it is hard for one to check (i.e. night) one may cook the egg without checking it for blood.
Today, many poskim say the metzius is that there are no roosters at egg farms so chickens do not mate and produce eggs which are fertile. Therefore, if one does find a blood spot in an egg, all he has to do is throw out the blood spot and he then may eat the rest of the egg.
Since eggs are inexpensive, rather than trying to remove a blood spot, some people still throw out the whole egg.
Harav Moshe Feinstein zt”l writes that according to the letter of the law one can remove the blood spot and eat the egg. However, he spoke to a farmer who said eggs are often mixed together – hatching eggs and table eggs. Therefore, since eggs are cheap and one does not have a big loss, one should be stringent and discard the entire egg. Since this teshuva was written in 1957 when the metzius may have been different than it is today, it would seem that even Harav Moshe zt”l would agree that nowadays one can be lenient. One who does check, should check for a red or dark spot. A brown spot is permitted.
In rural areas where eggs are sold at the farm or on the side of the road, it is possible to buy a fertilized egg. In this case it is best to check the eggs for blood spots.
When eating hard boiled eggs, Harav Moshe Feinstein zt”l had the custom to peel back the white to check the surface of the yolk for blood spots, which would appear as black spots.
When checking for blood spots, one should crack the egg in a cup where the egg can be seen from all sides.
Cooked
As mentioned before, according to the Rama, before using eggs in food, one should check to see if there are any blood spots. However, if it was not done, it is permitted to eat a hard boiled egg which was not checked beforehand since we can rely on the fact that most eggs are not fertilized. One who notices a blood spot on the food after it is cooked should remove the blood spot. This can occur when egg yolk is used to glaze challah or bread. The food is nonetheless permitted. One is permitted to eat a fried egg without checking for blood spots. This is permitted because most eggs do not contain bloodspots.
Boiling three Eggs
People would have a separate egg pot or cook three eggs at a time so if one of them would have a blood spot, it would be butel b’rov and all the eggs would be permitted. This is not necessary today, since the chance of finding a blood spot is very minimal since the eggs are not fertilized. Based on this, there is no reason to have a separate egg pot.
However, some still have the custom to wait twenty-four hours before using a utensil in which an egg that was not checked for blood was cooked. No hagala is required after the twenty-four hour period. One who put an egg with a blood spot in a hot frying pan does not have to kasher the pan.
Commercial Production
As mentioned above, checking for blood spots is a custom. Accordingly, if one is cooking for hundreds of people (i.e. a caterer or a school,) or it is dark, or if the food is made in a factory setting where checking is very difficult, one does not have to check the eggs for blood spots.
Frozen Eggs – Powdered Eggs
The poskim discuss whether one is permitted to purchase frozen or dried eggs from a non-Jew who did not inspect the eggs for their kashrus status. The opinion of some poskim is to be lenient, and this seems to be the custom.
Other Blemishes Found in an Egg Greening
when eggs are boiled for too long, the yolks will often turn green. This is not an indication of anything and may be eaten.