30 Jul DATING AND RELATIONSHIP ADVICE
Dear Rabbi and Shira,
I was dating a guy for 3 months, and I fell hard for him. We had common goals, and enjoyed speaking about all things
pre-law. We spoke night and day, and had a magic present, which is hard to describe After three months, he dumped me.
I understand why he wasn’t right for me, but now, a year later I’m dating a wonderful young man who I care about, we
share common interests, but that “spark” is not there. What should I do? I feel like I might be missing out on a different
great guy just because of something that I can’t quite put my finger on.
-Sparkless in Brooklyn
Hi Sparkless!
We’d like you to do a mental exercise. Can
you close your eyes and think about both of
these young men. Think about what was it
that excited you about this first guy? Was he
more attractive physically than your current
boyfriend, how so? Were there familial/
cultural factors which you found attractive,
what were they? How much time are you
spending with your current boyfriend, is
that different? Are you seeing your current
boyfriend too much? Are you seeing him too
little? Are you excited to be with him or are
you relieved when you are not with him?
Also, we’d like you to consider the following
thought. Is it possible you are more on
guard after the last incident, and are afraid
of “letting someone get close again?”
Sometimes, after a “let-down”, we are “on-
guard” not to let the same thing happen
again. You could be worrying that he could
at any moment dump you, just like the last
guy. One more alternative, maybe you are
comparing too much. Maybe you are asking
yourself if your experience will ever be as
good as it was with your ex.
Of course, there simply might not be the
chemistry between the two of you, despite
shared interests.
It’s normal to be a little on edge, or doubtful
about the future, but if you find yourself
unable to open up again and let your guard
down; you might consider speaking with a
professional to learn to trust again.
Good Luck!
Rabbi Reuven and Shira Boshnack.